If something 'adds up', it means it makes sense or seems reasonable.
Her explanation just didn’t add up.
A: Do you believe his story? B: Not really. Something doesn’t add up.
When I looked at the evidence, it didn’t add up, so I started to doubt the results.
Common mistake
✗Her story doesn't add up with the facts.
✓Her story doesn't add up. / Her story doesn't fit the facts.
'Add up' works alone here — don't tack 'with' on it.
Tell it apart
His alibi just doesn't add up.
doesn't make sense
The numbers don't add up.
the total is wrong
Use 'add up' when you think something is logical or believable, especially when talking about facts or stories.Not about numbers or math—this sense is about logic or believability.